The way to choose between FatSecret and kkal.ai for counting calories and macros is to run the dishes you usually eat through both. You can keep a kkal.ai food diary with photos, barcodes and manual editing. What decides it is which way of logging suits you best.
First determine what you want to change
Searching for “how to replace FatSecret” might mean you want to log lunch faster, check portions more conveniently or see daily totals more easily. Pick two or three scenarios that matter to you, then compare the apps on those. If your current diary already works for you, one new feature may not be reason enough to switch.
Calories from photos are available in both applications
In kkal.ai you can start an entry with a photo of a dish, then refine the ingredients. FatSecret has Smart Food Scan, which its official help describes as a Premium feature. So compare how convenient recognition and editing feel on your own dishes, and what the terms of access are. In any app, a photo is still an estimate you need to check.
Product database and usual diary
With FatSecret you get food database search, a food diary and barcode scanning. If your meals are already saved there and you regularly find the items you need, that's a good reason to stay with it. There's a diary and barcode scanner in kkal.ai too, so before you move your everyday tracking, try it on a few of the packages you buy most often.
Cost and Availability
You can download kkal.ai for free, though additional features may require an in-app purchase. FatSecret has free features and Premium. A free download doesn't mean free access to every feature. Open the one you want and compare the terms in your app store, since they may differ by platform and region.
Who should try kkal.ai
It's worth a look if you'd like your diary entries to start from a photo and you want to check calories and macros in one app. Begin with a few familiar meals and notice how easy it is to correct the ingredients, change the portion and look over the day's total. You'll learn more from this small test than from a general list of features.
kkal.ai and FatSecret: what to compare
| Scenario | kkal.ai | FatSecret |
|---|---|---|
| Recording by photo | Analysis of a dish with an estimate of calories and macros | Smart Food Scan; listed as Premium in the official help |
| Packaged Products | Barcode scanner in mobile application | Barcode scanner and database search |
| Food diary | Meals, daily totals and goals | Food diary and calorie and nutrient tracking |
| Payment terms | Free download, in-app purchases | Free and Premium features |
How to switch from FatSecret
- Save the entries that matter to you from your current diary, in whatever way you can.
- Install kkal.ai and set your goals again. Don't count on your history transferring automatically from FatSecret: that hasn't been confirmed here.
- Add a few dishes you know and check their ingredients and portions.
- See how logging and daily totals compare for convenience. After that, decide which app to keep for daily tracking.
Try kkal.ai at your usual lunch
Add a dish you know, check the portion and see if keeping a diary in the app feels comfortable. You'll find more on the home page. Purchase terms are in your app store.
More guides to replacing FatSecret
- FatSecret alternatives: what to use if it has stopped working
- How to switch from FatSecret to another calorie tracker
The kkal.ai team prepared this from official product descriptions. It compares stated capabilities, and accuracy wasn't independently tested. FatSecret and kkal.ai are separate products.